In December of 2000, I was driving to work, when I heard everyone's favorite radio racists, Steve and DC, talking about a new Christmas song, a song that was so beautiful that was destined to become a classic. The concept of a new Christmas song is pretty dicey at best, and the fact that this song was being performed by a group called Newsong wasn’t really all the encouraging.
For the next five minutes or so, I sat stupefied. While I expected some worthless tripe to poison my airwaves, I didn't expect a steaming pile of dog shit, horribly written, and badly executed to make my ears burn. It was like this song was written in some alternate universe Brill Building, completely calculated to make one’s eyes moist and one's heart feel all warm, a modern classic to remind us "what Christmas is all about."
Feh.
Sadly, this song does seem to touch people (there are legions of fans on the internet still raving about it, the novel it inspired and the tv movie inspired by the novel (Oh, Kimberly Williams, how utterly disappointed you must be in your career)). In my internet research, I’ve discovered that is monstrosity is "based on a true story." So, with my apologies to people who like this song, dead mothers, poor people, the "people" in the "true story" that inspired this song, and the people who work at Payless, I begin.
It was almost Christmas time, there I stood in another line
What is "almost Christmas time"? July? Christmas shit starts hitting the shelves in the summer, and by time Halloween is over, Thanksgiving is a one-day break from the runaway train that is Christmas, so as a listener, I’m already confused as to when this song takes place. I'm gonna go with Arbor Day.
Trying to buy that last gift or two, not really in a Christmas mood
Well, if it's only Arbor Day and he's on his last gift or two, he's doing pretty goddamn well (I've still only bought one gift at this point).
Standing right in front of me was a little boy waiting anxiously
Pacing 'round like little boys do
Now, any writing teacher worth their salt will tell you that describing anything as the way "little boys do," or "children often do" or whatever is just horrible, horrible writing. It's a total cop-out stylistically.
And in his hands he held a pair of shoes
And his clothes were worn and old, he was dirty from head to toe
And when it came his time to pay
Three lines in a row were started with the word "and." Three!
I couldn’t believe what I heard him say
Yeah, I wouldn’t believe it, either. Normally I don’t spit out some badly rhymed diatribe when I’m trying purchase a pair of shoes.
Chorus:
Sir, I want to buy these shoes, for my Mama, please
It's Christmas Eve
So it’s Christmas Eve, is it? How is that "almost Christmas time"? By Christmas Eve, Christmas is practically fucking over.
and these shoes are just her size
Who gives a tiny rats ass that the shoes are "just her size"? You're at a fucking shoe store, ostensibly at a mall. Unless Mama has some freakishly large or small feet the fact that these shoes are "just her size" isn't really worth mentioning, Tiger.
Could you hurry, sir, Daddy says there’s not much time
Time enough to be wandering the mall alone buying shoes, though
You see, she’s been sick for quite a while
Perhaps this child shouldn’t have waited to "almost Christmas time" to buy these fucking shoes
And I know these shoes would make her smile
Note - on my deathbed, please run to Payless so you can put one last smile on my face
And I want her to look beautiful, if Mama meets Jesus tonight
This line is just horseshit. We switched from "her" to "Mama" mid-sentence. There’s no agreement here. Horrible. HORRIBLE.
He counted pennies for what seemed like years
Again, bullshit line that would get you a lot of red ink on your paper in Writing 101. "Seemed like years"? Yawn.
But the fact that the little dirty boy with the dying mama has to pay in pennies is supposed to make your heart melt. "Aw, he’s gotta pay with pennies." I mean, I got a really nice pair of shoes at Payless a few months ago for $11.99, and while I’m pretty sure Mama’s goddamn gorgeous Jesus shoes must have cost more than that, even $11.99 worth of pennies is 1199 pennies. If the kid only had half of that, he’s carrying over five hundred pennies. No wonder he was pacing around anxiously (like little boys do). He’s totally weighted down by these pennies. What was he carrying them in, I wonder?
Then the cashier said, "Son, there’s not enough here."
He searched his pockets frantically (expecting to find a thousand pennies hidden in his Toughskins?)
Then he turned and looked at me
Here comes the unmitigated gall
He said, "Mama made Christmas good at our house
One has to wonder, was this grammatically frightening sentence was written to sound like folksy child-speak, of if the (I can’t even believe I’m going to use this word) "songwriter" was just a moronic hack. I'll let you be the judge.
Though must years she just did without
Without what? Christmas? Verbal ability?
Tell me, Sir, what I am gonna do?
Oh, I don't know. Go home and be with your dying mother! Nah, you should just rattle on a little longer. It's only "if" she meets Jesus tonight, not "when."
Somehow I’ve got to buy her these Christmas shoes"
This is the part where I always begin to wonder if this is just some sort of scam, and if Mama and Daddy are really out in the parking, drinking Jack Daniels and screwing in their El Camino, as their kid is in the mall holding up the line at a shoe store, trying to scam some stupid sap out of twenty bucks.
So I laid the money down
Hopefully not in pennies
I just had to help him out
I'll never forget the look on his face when he said,
"Mama’s gonna look so great."
If, as we're being led to believe, this woman is a cough away from biting the big one, how great exactly are these shoes going to make her look? In fact, would Christmas slippers be more appropriate? I don't really think Mama's gonna put these shoes on and start dancing around the house. I hope they have a low heel, at any rate.
Seriously, "Grandma Got Run Over By A Reindeer" is a better song. Or that one where the dogs bark "Jingle Bells."
There's another bullshit chorus, where you might notice that the singer is really hitting every syllable with the same emphasis, and they've really squeezed as many words as they possibly can in the is piece of crap.
I knew I’d caught a glimpse of Heaven’s love
As he thanked me and ran out
I'd be demanding that kid give me his address and the receipt, because those shoes would be going to back to the store on December 26th.
I knew that God had sent that little boy
To remind me what Christmas is all about
Filth? Cancer? Panhandling?
Then there’s a majestic child's choir, warbling out the chorus again, and then finally, mercifully, the song comes to an end, but not before a lone child’s voice, squeaks out the final, "If Mama meets Jesus tonight."
Call me a humbug, but this song doesn't warm my heart or make me think of what Christmas is all about. It just makes me angry.
Instead of writing my own conclusion, I thought I'd leave you with a random post I found about this song when I was doing my research. While I'm pleased with my analysis of the song, this writer really sums it up best:
This is the worst song ever. Call me heartless, but some little boy is not gonna be like "Hi, my mom needs shoes," and Jesus does not care about your shoes. If I were like the cashier, I'd be like, "Yo momma is not gonna meet Jesus, yo momma is gonna burn in HELL." God bless!









